29th Sunday in ordinary time
Isaiah 45:1,4-6
Matthew 22:15-21
We all know that when both politics and religion come up in a discussion, things can easily become explosive. Jesus was confronted with a question that linked both topics. It was a perfidious trap set for him by the Pharisees and Herod’s followers. The two groups were, in fact, hostile to one another. The only thing that united them was their hatred towards Jesus.
They asked him: ‘Is it lawful to pay taxes to the Caesar, or not?’ It made no difference whatsoever whether Jesus answered ‘yes’ or ‘no’. He could only lose.
Anyone who paid tax to the Emperor was regarded by the Pharisees as a political enemy, as a sympathiser with the occupying power. But from a religious point of view, too, this was highly problematic. The Emperor at the time, Tiberius, described himself as the ‘son of the divine Augustus’. The Romans often deified great emperors after their death by a resolution of the Senate. This was the case with Julius Caesar, and also with Augustus. In the eyes of the Romans, therefore, Tiberius was the son of a god. Paying him tax could be maliciously interpreted as offering a sacrifice to this son of a foreign god. So if Jesus had simply said, ‘Yes, one may pay tax to the Caesar’, the Pharisees could have accused him of being a political enemy and of having renounced faith in the true God.
But if he had said publicly, ‘No, one must not pay taxes to the Caesar’, then Herod’s supporters would have springing into action immediately and denounced him to the occupying power as a political rebel.
In fact, there was no way out of this trap. Yet Jesus managed it. With just one sentence: ‘Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s!’
Jesus’ reply astonished his listeners at the time. And it became the foundation for the specifically Christian way of shaping the relationship between politics and religion.
Jesus escapes the trap by assigning religion and politics to different spheres. The separation of religion and politics, which seems so modern to us, actually dates back to the Gospel.
‘Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s’: The Catechism of the Catholic Church speaks of a moral obligation ‘to pay taxes, to exercise the right to vote and to defend one’s country’ (CCC 2240). This moral obligation is based on ‘submission to authority’ and on ‘co-responsibility for the common good’. Christians are to recognise state authorities. Obedience is owed to them, within reasonable limits. Christians are no enemies of the secular state.
However, the state has no divine power. The Emperor is not God. Even the most powerful rulers in world history are not gods but merely instruments of the one God. Just like the Persian Cyrus, whom we heard about in the first reading. ‘The Lord says to his anointed, to Cyrus, whose right hand I have grasped, to subdue nations before him, […]: I call you by your name, I name you, though you do not know me. I am the Lord, and there is no other, besides me there is no God.’
State authority is not divine. It has limits. The limits of obedience to state authorities lie precisely where what belongs to God is touched upon. Christians have a duty to refuse obedience to state authorities as soon as they are ‘contrary to the demands of the moral order, to the fundamental rights of persons or the teachings of the Gospel’ (CCC 2242), as we read in the Catechism.
‘Render to God what is God’s’: what exactly is that which is God’s, to which the emperor has no right?
The tax coins bore the emperor’s image. They are therefore his property.
God’s property, then, must be everything that bears the image of God. In the opening pages of the Bible we read: ‘God created man in his own image; in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them.’ Every single human being bears the image of God. Therefore, every human being is God’s property. And God’s alone.
No state authority and no other human being can lay a legitimate claim of ownership over a human being. Human beings must not be treated like objects. Neither by the state nor by other people. One must not simply throw people away like objects when they are no longer of use. One must not plannedly produce them, select them or eliminate them if they do not fit into our plans. From the very first moment of existence, a human being belongs to God alone. Right up to the last breath. And beyond.
This is what should characterise all good state laws and rules: unconditional respect for human beings.
Every human being is made in the image of God. Even Caesar. That is why, ultimately, even the emperor himself belongs to God. Politics and religion are separate, but every politician must account for their actions before God in his conscience.
But it is not only politicians; we all must account before God. Give to God what belongs to God! We owe ourselves to God. Our whole life, everything we are and have. We are His property. For He created us. In His image.